Sunday, June 14, 2009

WHY CAPITALISM WORKS BEST


Why does capitalism work best? Capitalism works best because it is the only social and economic system that aligns itself with the combined human spirits of achievement, ambition, self-improvement, individualism, self-esteem, and initiative.

Capitalism is not perfect, by any means. No system made up of imperfect human beings has been, nor can be. However, capitalism comes closest in bringing out the best in society because it appeals to our highest ideals of individual rights which come in the form of economic freedom. Capitalism is a system based on the firm establishment of individual rights, including property rights, in which all property is privately owned.

Granted, and to the shocking surprise of some of you, this is not the system we have, or have had during the last century in the United States. When I say "capitalism," I mean pure, unadulterated, unfiltered, unregulated laissez-faire capitalism, with a total separation of the government from the economic system where the only real function of government is one of protecting individual rights (instead of studying tree frog mating habits or hog stench, etc.) and protecting him or her from physical force. We have a very small degree of free market capitalism today, but mostly are subject to never-ending federal "regulations" that micro-manage seemingly every business transaction, in one way or another.

Capitalism demands the very best of every person and rewards him or her according to his efforts and skills, accordingly. It allows anyone the freedom to choose the work or business of their skill and interest, and to trade that labor or product for either the equivalent monetary value, or an equally desirable product or service in trade (which the IRS would now still tax!). The value of a person's work is determined by the free market where there is a 100% correlation between the value added to society and the compensation earned in return. In true capitalism, it is the consumer is king.

There is such a plethora of distortion, misinformation, misrepresentation, and outright falsehoods about free market capitalism today that the upcoming generation of young people actually think that there may be other superior or equal systems to be tried, like socialism, which has failed to produce anywhere near the broad degree of wealth enjoyed by the people of the United States.

In a capitalist society, all transactions are voluntary. For example, banks would not be coerced to make loans to people that wouldn't be able to repay them for the "betterment" of society (the root of the current economic mess). No person or group may initiate the use of physical force against others.

"But wait," you say. "I thought we weren't a pure capitalist society, Mr. Capitalist." You are correct. We aren't. But, we have allowed more economic freedom than other countries which has correlated into more economic wealth for more people than any other place on the planet.

Share/Save/Bookmark

12 Comments:

  1. There is more than one definition of capitalism.
    ReplyDelete
  2. market economy is a subset of capitalism
    ReplyDelete
  3. I have posted an article today, and I'm going to put a link to this article in it. This article was also seeded on Newsvine.
    ReplyDelete
  4. try and show the horrids of socialism and communism in order to make capitalism look better... it works
    ReplyDelete
  5. For the most part, I tend to agree with most of what you have written in your blog; however, I don’t understand how you can argue for a "pure, unadulterated, unfiltered, unregulated laissez-faire capitalism, with a total separation of the government from the economic system."

    Because it seems to me, what you are advocating for is essentially to live in a society where no one is held accountable to anything except the profit margin. It doesn’t matter what good or service you sell, how you sell it, or whom you sell it, as long as an individual can make money doing it regardless of who it may hurt and no one can stop you.
    ReplyDelete
  6. @Mitchell: Ayn Rand, an advocate of Objectivist philosophy and, as a corollary, laissez-faire, understands that you are referring to fraud. Fraud is a form of physical coercion, by manipulating the consumer, and, thusly, is illegal.
    ReplyDelete
  7. I disagree completely with you in so many ways mr. blog writer Matthew Burke(?). I do not wish to be a troll and write a long article to show ALL the flaws of capitalism, as many people more educated than I have made perfectly compelling arguments.

    If you were one to listen to these arguments then your factually incorrect post would not exist, so there is no point in trying once again to make you understand.

    What I will simply do is point out a few things from this post.

    In the description of your pure idea of "capitalism" it involves a government that "is one of protecting individual rights... and protecting him or her from physical force."
    Is this not the micro-management that you decry in the next sentence?

    Should not individual rights be objectively decided by the market? In china where the worker=individual has little to no rights, the economy is booming.

    Tell your "achievement, ambition, self-improvement, individualism, self-esteem, and initiative" aligned capitalism story to a displaced and empoverished Chinese person. Please do not degrade yourself by arguing the equal opportunity, hard work equals reward fallacy.

    Oh but we are not talking about China, where the worlds largest middle class is currently swelling (along with social inequality). We are talking about USA, where economic inequality rates are close to the worst in the world.

    Capitalism is good for a few very lucky people. It appears you simply cannot see it from an "objective" point of view, as capitalism works for YOU.

    "No person or group may initiate the use of physical force against others," you say.

    Ok, lets have capitalism, but denounce physical force. What do you mean? Should police not have the use of physical force? Just to be pedantic, can firemen not use physical force to rescue...

    Forgive me that last line.

    "But, we have allowed more economic freedom than other countries which has correlated into more economic wealth for more people than any other place on the planet."

    Where is the proof? Proof of 1)more economic freedom than other contries 2)economic wealth for MORE people.

    I suggest that line should go "We (usa) were one of the first to allow these economic freedoms which has correlated into more economic wealth for a few people just like a lot of other places on the planet"

    Seems more honest.
    ReplyDelete
  8. My cousin almost died serving this country in Irag so it makes me sick to hear people talking negative about the USA.
    If you feel that way go live in China or Europe and denounce your U.S. Citizenship. Whoever makes comments about capitalism being inferior to socialism should apologize to everyone. It is Un-American to believe in a system that favors big government and props up/rewards unproductive people in society. It also allows the government to control, administer and spend more. Please name one thing the government has ever done that has been successful and efficient? Medicare/Medicaid? Social Security? Welfare? Fannie Mae? Freddie Mac? USPS? The successful/hard working/productive American people should not be punished and have to pay for the outrageous spending and unproductive people in society. In addition, all big government does is add layers of bureaucracy and corruption to programs that should be eliminated or privately run. Believe it or not I am not a Republican or a Tea Party member. I'm just a true American who loves my country and believes that Capitalism and Democracy is a formula for success.
    ReplyDelete
  9. I am truely sorry to hear about your cousin. I am happy that he is still alive.

    My comment was not negative about the USA's armed forces in Iraq, it was against "unregulated..." capitalism as described by this post. My comment was about the unequal distribution of wealth as a result of this capitalism. This is not only just in USA.

    I did not say that capitalism is inferior to socialism!

    Why do we live in a world where ideas are so polar? If someone does not like something in USA, they HATE EVERYTHING ABOUT AMERICA! (from your "Un-american" idea, did you know that America is a continent, not a country?) If someone does not like the way capitalism is currently working THEY ARE A COMMIE SOCIALIST!

    I believe you, you are a true American who loves your country. I would hazard a guess that you are also a relatively well off person, for whom captialism and democracy works (well, you do have access to a computer to comment on this page, so that puts you very high up on the list). What about the hard working, marginalised, struggling poor population in USA? Do you refuse to believe they exist? Or if they do exist, do you think they are just unproductive and should starve to death? There is not only unequal distribution of wealth, but unequal distribution of opportunity EVEN in the USA. Many work long long hours and try their hardest to succeed but are exploited by capitalism, and remain in poverty. Should the population as a whole be so selfish, egocentric and selfserving that they deny anything they can, in the name of competition, from anyone else?

    If you think this, and believe I am being "un-american" by saying what I just said, you are simply living in a simulated society where only your opinion counts regardless of any fact or truth.

    But after all that, I agree with you. Democracy and Capitalism is a formula for success. The 1 vote=one person MUST work properly, and NOT be infringed upon by the big money that capitalism creates. Democracy MUST regulate capitalism.
    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for pointing out that America is a continent, I wish you could put a bib on me and wipe up my drool too.

    Aside from your pompous attitude, I absolutely respect your opinion and desire for what is best for the United States.
    (By the way, I'm speaking of the United States of America, not the United States of Mexico, because we are talking about this country)

    I agree that we polarize things more than necessary, but this is a subject that many are passionate about... and people seem to take things they are passionate about to the extremes. I just wanted to point out that from my research I believe that Capitalism works best. Sadly, this doesn't mean that everyone will be happy, healthy, and have money to get what they want. (I am speaking of capitalism that is mostly unregulated)

    I am a working student, and I am about to go into debt for optometry school. I am on my own, and I know that if I stay determined and focused I can be successful.

    No need to point out that not everyone can do that, I believe that's true. However, there are more people in the United States of America that can decide on their life goal and achieve it than any country that I know of. (I am not saying that there aren't any. If you know of some point them out for me and I would love to research them ).

    I don't have much money to my name, so I'm not saying this with any ulterior motives. Soon I will be in debt for a few years, but I anticipate being well off. That was not something that I received from a corrupt system that favored me. The main point that I want to get across is that I do not come from wealth, but I believe that I can achieve wealth.

    Believe what you want, but the progress that capitalism has caused in modern society is unlike any other in history. Capitalism fuels entrepreneurs and success, maybe driven for selfish reasons, but ultimately everyone (not everyone, the majority) benefits.

    Don't assume that I am ignorant for the conclusions I have drawn from the books that I have read. I believe that you are intelligent—you have come to a different conclusion. That's fine. However, if you believe that the United States is unfair, I kindly suggest that you move. I would like to see the country revert back to a smaller government, because I strongly believe that we will be more prosperous if we stop pretending that giant governments that receive money whether or not they are successful (unlike a company) know how best to use money.

    Who will take care of the poor and those without equal opportunity? Their churches, their families and their friends. If you have never had to turn to one of those three at any point in your life, you are incredibly fortunate.

    Hope you're having a good sunday. Thanks for reading this (if you could stay awake through it :) )
    ReplyDelete
  11. just carry on consuming more and more as pushed by the church of capitalism until we run out of resources and then use our capitalist made weapons to take what we deserve from a more backward country. Why wait for that why not just buy up the country and stip mine it for our benefit(look whats currently happening in africa). When will these people understand that this free for all in the name of profit will have to be controlled to limit the damage to our world and not just bury their heads in the sand and pretend that their country/system is right ans sod the rest of the worlds population (god help us all when the third world want all the products/energy we currently consume)
    ReplyDelete
  12. I just want to point out the fact that both pedrolius and theoptometrist did an awesome job of not letting emotion and rhetoric overpower logic. Although each of you MIGHT have taken one or two cheap shots--O.K. you both did BUT...--they were elegantly written. If anything, the shots gave your op-ed writing more character because they were brief and comical (as opposed to making your entire post an emotionally charged rant belittling "liberals" or "conservatives").

    I wish our current politicians had the ability to debate politics the way that you both did. I encourage both of you to continue posting back and forth.
    ReplyDelete

Thank you for your comments. I appreciate your input!